Mustang Sallys Ignition Saga
My 109 has a General Motors/Holden 3.3 litre (202
cu.in.) six cylinder engine. When planning the installation, I always intended to fit an
electronic ignition module built from a kit of parts. This is really just a
transistor-assisted ignition which retains the points but uses them only for triggering
rather than as a switch for heavy coil current. The design was developed by an
Australian electronics magazine and is described more fully on the Electronic Ignition page. Its use of a fixed duration spark and an
extended "dwell" time for the coil gives a higher energy spark at all
engine speeds. An ordinary ignition coil is used, in my case a ballast-resistor type from
Bosch.
The distributor was also a Bosch and I'd taken it apart, verified that
the shaft bearing bushes were in perfect order, that the centrifugal advance unit moved
freely and that the vacuum advance capsule was working. The electronic module was built,
bench tested and installed. This module also has input circuitry for a Hall-effect device
or a reluctor-type trigger found in more recent distributors. The Bosch ignition catalogue
lists a Hall-effect trigger and interrupter vane which can be retrofitted to older Bosch
distributors but I thought that the points type triggering would be good enough for me.
I settled into a debugging and refinement period after the Land Rover
was registered for the road. It went well enough, though I thought it seemed a little
unwilling to rev. I put this down to its state of tune as a later de-toxed version of the
Holden Red six.
Then came the ignition dèbacle described in A
Text-book case. I began to wonder whether I should
try the ignition advance curve used in the earlier pre-emissions law version of the
3.3litre engine. The advance was restricted in the later models, though precise
details aren't easy to obtain. Later Holden 3.3's also had a gearbox switch to allow
vacuum advance only in top gear, only after the engine had reached operating temperature
and only six degrees of vacuum advance in any case. There is no such gearbox switch in my
Land Rover so I'd already abolished the top-gear-only restriction and fitted an older
vacuum capsule which permitted more advance under part-throttle/light load conditions.. I
find, by the way, that vacuum advance capsules are no longer made for those Bosch
distributors so I am adding every serviceable one I see to my lifetime supply of spares.
Well, I gave my distributor to the local Bosch service depot and explained how I wanted it
to match the advance curve used for the earlier engines. When I collected it again, I
learned that the centrifugal advance mechanism had been totally worn out. The technician
showed me the two bobweight pivot pins he'd replaced. They were worn nearly half way
through. Though the unit looked and moved OK when at rest, a run on the distributor
test machine showed the bobweights sticking and binding on the pivots which restricted the
advance very badly. After repair, the mechanism was adjusted to the desired advance curve.
After refitting the distributor, the difference
was stunning. Acceleration through the gears was very noticeably better and highway fuel
consumption improved by three miles per Imperial gallon. The comparatively small bill from
the Bosch serviceman was money well spent, as I'd learned that centrifugal advance units
can look alright and still be totally unserviceable. Something to keep in mind when
working on other old klunkers of any make.
This should have been the end of the story, except
that I still wasn't happy with the performance of the points. Sure, they did not burn or
pit because they were only being asked to trigger the ignition module while passing just
enough current to keep them clean. However, the rubbing block still wears so that the
points gap needs readjustment at intervals. Not the "set and forget" system I
was hoping for.
But there is hope for any Holden Red six, in the
form of the Bosch breakerless electronic distributor fitted to the VC and VH Commodore
"Blue" engines from 1980 to 1984. The abolition of points came to Australia
somewhat later than in the USA where breakerless ignition in domestic cars dates from the
early '70s. The Bosch reluctor type distributor was used for four years in Holdens and a
nearly identical one appeared in contemporary Ford Falcons. In 1984, the VK Holden
Commodore featured the final black-painted version of the ancient red engine with either
an Electronic Spark Timing engine management system or the full Bosch Jet-tronic EFI.
The beauty of this Bosch breakerless distributor
is that it will fit any Holden Red six from the 1963 EH model onwards. It is a popular
conversion for older Holdens because it gives slightly improved economy, a slightly
smoother idle, better starting in adverse weather conditions and is virtually
maintenance-free. Unfortunately, its desirability is reflected in its price and scarcity.
A perfect Economics 101 illustration of the Law of Supply and Demand!
I got mine over the phone from Barsby Spare Parts
in Maryborough, Queensland, a firm of specialist Holden breakers. The thing was
purchased, sight unseen for $180 Australian and arrived in the mail a few days later. The
price was right, according to the word on the street, and I got exactly what I was
promised; a used Bosch electronic distributor in clean condition, in working order with
new shaft bushes fitted and including the correct Bosch ignition coil. A very satisfying
buying experience and well worth a mention in the Links section.
Description and Fitting
The electronic distributor is somewhat larger in
diameter than the one it replaces and the distributor cap and rotor arm are of different
dimensions. The High Tension lead terminals on the cap and ignition coil are male fittings
resembling a spark plug top rather than the sockets found on the points type distributor
so a new set of plug leads is required. The distributor does not have electronic advance.
It has a centrifugal advance unit hidden away below the reluctor assembly and a vacuum
advance capsule acting on a moving plate carrying the pickup stator. These need to be
checked for serviceability. I recommend a checkup by a distributor specialist if in doubt.
The pickup stator consists of an iron ring a
couple of inches wide with a coil of wire of about 1000 ohms resistance wound around it.
The inside of the ring has six triangular "teeth" spaced 60° apart. The rotor
or reluctor is an iron vane with six similar teeth keyed to the distributor shaft and
rotating inside the stator. The peaks of the reluctor teeth pass very close to the peaks
of the stator teeth every 60° of reluctor rotation. Every time this happens, the
magnetic field surrounding the pickup coil changes and a voltage pulse is induced in the
wire which serves to trigger the electronic module. As the moving parts never contact each
other, the ignition triggering components don't wear or need regular adjustment.
The electronic module hides on a platform under an
easily removable metal dust-cover on the side of the distributor base. It is an anonymous
looking black plastic oblong with four screw terminals. The leftmost ones marked 3 and 7
go to the reluctor pickup coil inside the distributor. The one marked 16 goes to the
negative terminal of the coil. The one marked 15 is the power terminal for the module and
goes to +12 volts from the ignition switch. This switched 12 volts can be conveniently
found at the positive terminal of the coil. If your previous ignition coil was a 7volt
type fed by a ballast resistor, the ballast resistor must be bypassed as the the
breakerless coil needs the full 12 volts.
The plastic module should be firmly screwed down
on a smear of silicon heatsink compound as it contains the high current switching
transistor which turns the coil primary current on and off in place of the conventional
points. Information about this electronics module is scarce but I gather that it uses the
same fixed duration spark/extended dwell concept as the box I made.
The fitting of this distributor to the engine is
similar to the procedure for replacing the original points distributor.
When preparing to remove the old distributor,
remove the distributor cap, take all the sparkplugs out and turn the engine until No.1
cylinder at the front is at TDC on the compression stroke with both valves closed. The
notch on the crankshaft pulley should be in line with the longest timing mark on the pad
cast into the front of the engine. The rotor arm will be pointing at a faint scored line
on the top edge of the distributor base which indicates the firing position for No.1
cylinder.
If the rotor arm is not pointing at the No.1 mark,
the engine is not at TDC for No.1 cylinder. But if all is OK, remove the clamp piece and
bolt at the base of the distributor and withdraw the distributor, noting how the rotor arm
turns clockwise a little as the helical drive gear unmeshes from the gear inside the
engine. Do not disturb the engine from now on or you will have to find TDC on No.1
cylinder again.
On the new electronic distributor, look for the
faint scored line indicating the firing position for No.1 cylinder. Rotate the distributor
shaft so that the rotor arm is at about the same position clockwise from the line as the
rotor arm was on the old distributor when you were completing withdrawal. Slide the
distributor into the engine. As the gears move into mesh, the rotor arm will move
anti-clockwise to finish up pointing at the No.1 firing mark. You may have to try again if
you miscalculated on the first attempt. Replace the clamp piece and bolt and do it up
lightly. Turn the engine anti-clockwise slightly so that the pulley notch lines up with
the 6 degree initial advance line on the crankcase. Rotate the distributor slightly so
that the six points on the star shaped reluctor rotor line up with the six points on the
stator ring. Tighten up the clamp bolt. You now have an initial setting sufficient to
start the engine and refine the timing further using a dynamic timing strobe light.
Ignition Coil
I received the correct ignition coil with the
distributor. However, I tend to be suspicious of second hand coils. The Bosch catalogue
lists a replacement coil HEC716 for electronic ignition which I purchased. This is quite
unlike the oil filled coil originally used, being an epoxy potted "transformer"
coil wound on an E shaped laminated iron core. It has a mounting bracket supplied which
suits the original mounting point on the side of the engine. The original connecting leads
attached to the distributor fit straight on to the terminal hardware supplied with the
coil.
In Service
The new distributor was fitted as described and the
engine started on the first turn of the key. After refining the timing, the engine seemed
to idle more smoothly and the performance was comparable to the reconditioned points
distributor with home-built electronics box. In both cases, the coolant temperature is a
couple of degrees lower than it was when I first put the Land Rover on the road. This will
be because the spark is no longer chronically retarded. I carry the safely wrapped up
points distributor and plug leads in the toolbox for fitting in the unlikely event that
the electronic distributor fails miles from anywhere. The points-type coil remains fitted
in the engine compartment.
According to the designer, my home-built electronic
ignition box can be driven by the reluctor pickup in the new distributor. On the other
hand, the Bosch module seems to do the same job and is neatly integrated with the
distributor so I'm not inclined to experiment just at present while everything is going
well.
For what its worth, here is a table with the part
numbers for the electronic distributor.
Description |
Part Numbers and comments |
Bosch Electronic ignition
distributor |
9 230 064 700
U - TGFU 6
GMH 9204493 |
Rotor button |
923 1064 306
Bosch Parts Store Number GB 827 |
Distributor Cap |
9 231 065 512
Bosch Parts Store Number GB 829 |
Electronic Module |
050 9 222 067 016
/ 017
Terminal Codes
3 & 7 black to reluctor, 15 pink to +12V, 16 green to
coil Neg. |
Original Bosch Electronic Coil
Oil filled can |
922 006 1446
U - KO 12V
GMH 92004875 143
Primary resistance .9 ohm.
Secondary resistance 6950 ohms. |
Current Bosch replacement Coil
|
HEC716
E core transformer, epoxy encapsulated |
Bosch Plug Leads |
|
|